What companion apps keep
Three independent studies, two exposed databases, and the five lines to find in any privacy policy.
Before you pay for an AI companion, we read its price list, its privacy policy and its house rules, check its public record, and score what we find. Then we tell you which one we would pick.
Out of 10, from four pillars: privacy, price clarity, track record, and rules and age checks. These are desk scores. None of these tools has been tested hands-on by us yet, and a second score will say so when one has.
Stories encrypted on your own device and flat, published prices. Its terms say almost nothing about content.
Paper score 6.8/10
The strongest privacy design for chat, with public prices. Its age rules are the thinnest we read.
Paper score 6.8/10
Written red lines and an age check that keeps your ID away from the app. The price only appears at checkout.
Paper score 6.4/10
Public prices and the strictest real-person ban we read. Your chats can train its models.
Paper score 6.3/10
Detailed content rules and narrow, well-explained age checks. A three-year-old privacy policy that is silent on chats.
Paper score 5.3/10
One flat plan and no ad networks. Thin written rules, and training archives that outlive your account.
Paper score 4.8/10
The most specific privacy policy we read, set against hidden prices and a €5 million fine.
Paper score 4.8/10
Not yet fully scored:
Published prices, grandfathered subscribers and detailed character rules. Privacy not yet scored.
Paper score 7.4*/10
* Provisional: one pillar could not be assessed. See the full comparison or how a score is built.
Four things people ask before they sign up, and the tool we would choose for each on the evidence we have.
Which one keeps my writing private?
NovelAI
Stories are encrypted on your own device before they are stored. For chat rather than stories, Venice.
Read the NovelAI reviewWhich companion app has the clearest rules?
Kindroid
Three written red lines, automated checks, and an age check that never hands Kindroid your ID.
Read the Kindroid reviewWhich tells me the real price up front?
Candy AI
Every price on a public page, down to the name on your bank statement. Watch the tokens.
Read the Candy AI reviewIs there anything decent for free?
Janitor AI
Free roleplay on its own model. Read our note on its 2023 privacy policy first.
Read the Janitor AI reviewThree names people search for that are not what they hope. Dated, with sources.
Paused
Announced in October 2025, delayed twice, shelved in March 2026. There is no setting to turn on.
Retired
Launched July 2025, reported retired from 1 September 2026. A reminder that a companion can be switched off.
Not allowed
No sexually explicit content, for adults or anyone else. Under-18s barred from character chat since November 2025.
What these products keep, what they cost once the intro price ends, who asks for ID, and where the law now draws the line.
Three independent studies, two exposed databases, and the five lines to find in any privacy policy.
Sticker prices, renewal prices, tokens and the name on your statement, from eight price lists.
Which tools verify age, where, through whom, and the laws behind it.
What changed in 2025 and 2026, which tools ban real-person content in writing, and what to do if it happens to you.
What the policy lets the company do with your chats: train on them, keep them, share them, read them.
Whether you can see the real cost before you sign up, and how refunds and renewals are written.
Fines, breaches, lawsuits and sudden changes on the public record, and whether the operator is named.
Whether the limits are written down, including on minors and real people, and whether adults are verified.
What we have not done. We have not used these products. A desk score tells you what a company has committed to in writing and what is on the public record. It cannot tell you how good the conversation is. Each review has a marked place for hands-on notes, and it stays empty until someone has paid for the plan and run the tests.